• Home
    • Law Firm Profile
  • Αρχικη
  • ГЛАВНАЯ
  • People
    • Savvas A. Angelides >
      • Social
    • Michael O. Ioannides >
      • Blog Posts
      • Social
    • Andreas N. Leonidou >
      • Social
    • Christos O. Ioannides >
      • Social
    • Theodoros Makris >
      • Social
    • Maria Angelides
    • Panayiota Zacharia
    • Constantinos Pavlou
    • Loukas Karnos
    • Argyroulla Ignatiou
    • Michalis Argyrou
    • Maria Panayiotou
    • Sissy Zhang
    • Antonia Constantinou
  • ΑΝΘΡΩΠΟΙ
  • Kоманда
  • Litigation
    • Commercial Litigation >
      • People
    • Criminal Litigation >
      • People
    • Medical Negligence >
      • People
    • Personal Injuries >
      • People
    • Class Actions >
      • People
    • Banking Litigation >
      • People
  • ΔΙΚΑΣΤΗΡΙΟ
  • СУДЕБНАЯ ПРАКТИКА
  • Advisory
    • Financial Services >
      • Experience
      • Resources
      • People
    • Corporate >
      • Services
      • Resources
      • People
    • Educational Services >
      • People
  • ΣΥΜΒΟΥΛΕΥΤΙΚΟ
  • КОНСУЛЬТАТИВНЫЕ УСЛУГИ
    • Финансовые Услуги
    • Корпоративные Услуги >
      • Услуги
  • Services
    • Alternative Funds (AIF)
    • Mutual Funds (UCITS)
    • EU Investor Passports
    • Permanent Residence Permit
    • Yacht Leasing Scheme
    • Cyprus International Trusts
    • Cyprus Investment Firms (CIF)
    • Payment Institutions
    • Electronic Money Institutions
  • ΥΠΗΡΕΣΙΕΣ
  • УСЛУГИ
    • Альтернативные Фонды
    • Mutual Funds (UCITS)
    • Паспорт Инвестора ЕС
    • Permanent Residence Permit
    • Yacht Leasing Scheme
    • Cyprus International Trusts
    • Cyprus Investment Firms (CIF)
    • Payment Institutions
    • Electronic Money Institutions
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Επαφη
  • КОНТАКТЫ

Analysis of the recent Greek Court decision for foreign currency loans 

18/9/2015

1 Comment

 
Picture
Of maximum importance is the recent decision of the Athens Court of First Instance, which clearly follows the trend of other Courts of foreign countries, with similar decisions, on the very important issue of borrowing in Swiss Francs.

In the said decision the application of  the consumers was accepted, represented by the LLPO Law Firm  through their Greek branch LLPO Law Firm - Ioannides & Makris and an order was issued against the Bank, which orders the Bank to  accept, until the final decision on the main action of the consumers for cancelation of the loan agreement as abusive, payment by the consumers of monthly  instalments of the loan contract, with the exchange rate of the Swiss Franc in Euro, as established during the implementation of the disbursement of the loan amount, which was as agreed at the conclusion of the original contract.

The decision analyzes extensively the Directives of the European Union, as these were incorporated into the National Law of the country and it is emphasized, that a contract term which was not the subject of individual negotiation is considered to be abusive, if it is created at the expense of the consumers and a significant imbalance between the rights and the obligations of the parties, arise from this contract.

The principle of transparency is emphasized, according to which the general terms of negotiations must be drafted clearly and understandably, so that the consumers are able to diagnose in advance, crucial elements of the contract, such as the duration and sizes.
In this case, upon the signing of the loan agreement, the consumers were not informed by the Bank's employees for the foreign exchange risk of the equality of the Swiss Franc and Euro, nor themselves had any property or income in Swiss Francs, in order for the Bank to be justified, as seems to be implied by the Court itself, in the suggestion of such a borrowing by the Bank.

Moreover the functioning of the exchange rate, the method and the specificities of the domestic currency conversion mechanism to foreign currency, were not clearly defined, so that consumers to be in a position to appreciate the financial consequences of such a borrowing and particularly to be able to diagnose in advance the amount of the instalments that will be required to pay and the issue of outstanding capital, in case the exchange rate between the Euro and Swiss Franc was varied on the burden of the consumers. 
The result of all these, was that the consumers were not in a position, in a proposed contract, to know nor be able to understand, what kind of contractual commitments were undertaken.It was stressed in the decision, that it is not enough, a term of a contract to be clearly formulated grammatically, so as to be determined as valid, if there is substantial ambiguity on its financial implications.

We are sorry to note that the whole issue of borrowing in Swiss Francs affects thousands of borrowers and guarantors, which have contracted such foreign currency loans, resulting with outstanding balances of their loans to be now much higher, from the disbursed amount of the loan and these consumers to be called today to pay these sums in instalments, of unimaginable height.

It seems to be certain that such kind of legal actions will be raised before our own Cypriot Courts . 

Maria Aggelides
Lawyer
Head of Banking Department
LLPO Law Firm - Angelides, Ioannides LLC Leonidou

1 Comment
M Anastasiades
22/9/2015 19:14:19

Please update me on the latest on the court decision for the Swiss francs mortgage decisions
For bank of Cyprus

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    October 2016
    September 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    April 2014
    March 2014
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    November 2010

    Categories

    All
    Accident
    Alert
    Andreas Leonidou
    Bail In
    Banking
    Betting
    Business
    CFC
    CHF
    Christos Ioannides
    CIF
    Citizenship
    Company
    Corporate
    Criminal Law
    CSE
    Customs
    Cylon
    Cyprus
    CySEC
    David Anderson
    Depositors
    Dividends
    Double Tax Treaties
    ECM
    Education
    Enviromental
    Eurogroup
    Europe
    Exclusive Economic Zone
    Financial
    Finland
    Foreign Currency
    Forum
    Framework
    Fraud
    Gambling
    Greece
    Health & Safety
    ICIS
    India
    Innovation
    Investors
    IP
    Law
    Lawsuit
    Legislation
    Levy
    Luxemburg
    Maria Panayiotou
    Michael Ioannides
    News
    NOMAD
    Oil And Gas
    Passport
    Portugal
    Property
    Property Rights
    Real Estate
    Residence Permit
    Russia
    Securities
    Spain
    Switzerland
    Tax
    Ukraine
    Unitary Patent
    United Kingdom
    Universities
    VAT
    Yacht

    RSS Feed

Cyprus (Head Office)

15, Agion Omologiton Avenue,
1080, Nicosia, 

Cyprus
✆ +357 (22) 452600 
⎙ +357 (22) 452611

Greece

34, Voukourestiou,
4th floor, 10671, Athens (Kolonaki),
Greece
✆ +30 (210) 3617152
⎙ +30 (210) 3617153

Romania

4 Plata Alba-Iulia Street, Block I3, Scara A, Etaj 11, Office 52, Sector 3,  ​Bucharest, Romania
✆ +40 (21) 3177350
⎙ +40 (21) 3177351

Picture
   info@llpolawfirm.com
© 2015 LLPO Law Firm. All Rights Reserved.
✕